24/25Union Omaha → Without Club—
23/24Without Club → Union Omaha—
23/24Sacramento FC → Without Club—
21/22Charleston → Sacramento FC—
18/19Hafnarfjördur → Charleston—
18/19HK Kópavogs → Hafnarfjördur—
18/19Hafnarfjördur → HK Kópavogs—
17/18New York → Hafnarfjördur—
17/18NYRB II → New York—
16/17New York → NYRB II—
16/17Boston Eagles → New York—
16/17Boston Rams → Boston Eagles—
15/16Boston Eagles → Boston Rams—
15/16Boston Rams → Boston Eagles—
14/15Boston Eagles → Boston Rams—
14/15Boston Rams → Boston Eagles—
13/14Boston Eagles → Boston Rams—
13/14Black Rock FC → Boston Eagles—
12/13Bermuda Hogges → Black Rock FC —
11/12Black Rock FC → Bermuda Hogges—
11/12Bermuda Hogges → Black Rock FC —
10/11Black Rock FC → Bermuda Hogges—
09/10Dandy Town FC → Black Rock FC —
