23/24Miami FC → HFX Wanderers—
22/23Columbus 2 → Miami FC—
21/22Without Club → Columbus 2—
21/22Atl. Ottawa → Without Club—
20/21Without Club → Atl. Ottawa—
20/21York United → Without Club—
19/20Nea Salamis → York9 FC—
19/20Toronto → Nea Salamis—
19/20York9 FC → Toronto—
18/19Toronto → York9 FC—
17/18Toronto FC II → Toronto—
16/17Vaughan Azzurri → Toronto FC II—
16/17York Lions → Vaughan Azzurri—
14/15Without Club → York Lions—
12/13Mississauga FC → Without Club—
