22/23Miami FC → Retired—
21/22Sligo Rovers → Miami FC—
20/21New Mexico Utd. → Sligo Rovers—
19/20Sligo Rovers → New Mexico Utd.—
18/19Pittsburgh → Sligo Rovers—
16/17ADI Metapán → Pittsburgh—
16/17Without Club → ADI Metapán—
15/16Pittsburgh → Without Club—
15/16ADI Metapán → Pittsburgh—
13/14Boys' Town FC → ADI Metapán—
12/13Tivoli Gardens → Boys' Town FC—
11/12Highgate United → Tivoli Gardens—
11/12St. George's SC → Highgate United—
