24/25Hartford → San Antonio FC—
23/24Memphis 901 → Hartford—
21/22Indy Eleven → Memphis 901—
20/21Memphis 901 → Indy Eleven—
20/21Without Club → Memphis 901—
19/20New York → Without Club—
19/20NYRB II → New York—
18/19New York → NYRB II—
18/19Indiana Hoosier → New York—
16/17Chicago FC → Indiana Hoosier—
15/16Indiana Hoosier → Chicago FC—
15/16Indy Academy → Indiana Hoosier—
