25/26Club Sando → Central FC—
23/24KFK Kópavogur → Club Sando—
21/22Without Club → KFK Kópavogur—
20/21Sacachispas → Without Club—
20/21Jocoro → Sacachispas—
19/20Switchbacks FC → Jocoro—
17/18Pittsburgh → Switchbacks FC—
16/17CD Dragón → Pittsburgh—
16/17Central FC → CD Dragón—
14/15Alpha United → Central FC—
14/15Central FC → Alpha United—
13/14Rangers → Central FC—
12/13SJ Jabloteh → Rangers—
09/10Tobago United FC → SJ Jabloteh—
