25/26North Carolina → Sporting JAX—
23/24Miami FC → North Carolina—
21/22North Carolina → Miami FC—
20/21Without Club → North Carolina—
20/21Örebro SK → Without Club—
19/20Gefle → Örebro SK—
18/19Philadelphia → Gefle—
18/19Bethlehem Steel → Philadelphia—
17/18Philadelphia → Bethlehem Steel—
17/18Bethlehem Steel → Philadelphia—
16/17Philadelphia → Bethlehem Steel—
16/17Houston → Philadelphia—
16/17Tulsa Hurricane → Houston—
16/17P. Timbers U23 → Tulsa Hurricane—
15/16Tulsa Hurricane → P. Timbers U23—
14/15Orange C. U23 → Tulsa Hurricane—
13/14Tulsa Hurricane → Orange C. U23—
13/14Chivas USA Aca. → Tulsa Hurricane—
USA