25/26Unknown → Belmopan—
24/25CV Fuego FC → Unknown—
23/24Without Club → CV Fuego FC—
23/24Tormenta FC → Without Club—
21/22Stumptown → Tormenta FC—
21/22Without Club → Stumptown—
20/21Charleston → Without Club—
19/20Without Club → Charleston—
18/19FIU Panthers → Without Club—
18/19FC Miami City → FIU Panthers—
17/18FIU Panthers → FC Miami City—
14/15SMU Mustangs → FIU Panthers—
13/14Solar SC → SMU Mustangs—
