25/26Miami FC → Loudoun United—
24/25El Paso → Miami FC—
23/24Miami FC → El Paso—
20/21Legion FC → Miami FC—
19/20Nashville SC → Legion FC—
17/18North Carolina → Nashville SC—
16/17Bethlehem Steel → North Carolina—
15/16NYRB II → Bethlehem Steel—
14/15Seton Hall → NYRB II—
14/15NJ-LUSO → Seton Hall—
13/14Seton Hall → NJ-LUSO—
13/14NYRB U-23 → Seton Hall—
12/13Seton Hall → NYRB U-23—
12/13NYRB U-23 → Seton Hall—
11/12Seton Hall → NYRB U-23—
11/12NYRB U-23 → Seton Hall—
10/11Seton Hall → NYRB U-23—
10/11NYRB Academy → Seton Hall—
