24/25Tulsa → San Antonio FC—
23/24Spokane → Tulsa—
23/24Union Omaha → Spokane—
22/23New Mexico Utd. → Union Omaha—
21/22Louisville City → New Mexico Utd.—
17/18BGSU Falcons → Louisville City—
17/18Michigan Bucks → BGSU Falcons—
16/17BGSU Falcons → Michigan Bucks—
16/17Michigan Bucks → BGSU Falcons—
15/16BGSU Falcons → Michigan Bucks—
15/16NDC Falcons → BGSU Falcons—
14/15Le Havre B → NDC Falcons—
